How to Taste Extra Virgin Olive Oil at Home: A 4-Step Tasting Guide

Have I convinced you that bitter and spicy are good for your health? If you missed the previous article, you can find it HERE .

Good. But now I see you: you're there in the kitchen, holding your bottle of new oil—maybe you paid a little more than usual—and you're wondering, "Now what? How do I know if it's worth all that? Have they ripped me off?"

You don't need a white coat or a chemical lab. To become a little expert and avoid being fooled by labels, all you need is your senses and a small glass. Like Il SommOlier , today I'll guide you through the "ceremony" of professional tasting (or Panel Test ), adapted to your kitchen. Put away the bread (for now) and follow these 4 steps .

Move 1: Preparation (Warming up the engines)

First rule of the " SommOlier Fight Club ": no coffee, tobacco, toothpaste, or strong perfumes at least 30 minutes before tasting. They alter the senses and distort judgment.

Get a small glass. A coffee glass is fine, but a tulip-shaped glass that tapers toward the top to trap odors would be ideal.

1. Pour in about a tablespoon of oil (a generous "sip").
2. Now do something that may seem strange to you: heat the oil . Hold the glass in the palm of one hand (to heat the bottom) and cover the opening with the other hand, like a lid.
3. Swirl the oil gently for 1-2 minutes.

Why do we do this? The goal is to bring the oil to around 28°C . At this exact temperature, the aromatic molecules (volatile compounds) "wake up" and rise, concentrating under your hand, ready to be discovered.

Step 2: The Smell Test (The Nose Doesn't Lie)

Remove your hand that's acting as a lid and... take a sniff right away. Don't just take a shy sniff. Take two or three deep breaths, trying to capture every nuance.

What You Need to Hear (The Merits)

The absolute highlight is called Fruity . You should taste the fresh, healthy olive. But don't stop there: close your eyes and search your olfactory memory for other memories.

• Do you smell freshly cut grass?
• Raw artichoke or cardoon?
• Green tomato, fresh almond, or white apple? Aromatic herbs? If you smell these "green" and fresh aromas, you're on the path to excellence.

What You Should NOT Hear (The Warning Bells)

If you don't smell anything (flat oil) or, worse, you smell musty, vinegary, painty, or cellary, put the glass down. We have a serious problem (see the defects section below).

Move 3: The "Stripping" (The Annoying Noise)

This is the funniest part (and the one that will make your dinner guests laugh). Put a small sip of oil in your mouth. Don't swallow it right away! Hold it there.

Now you need to do the stripping . Grit your teeth, open your lips slightly, and forcefully draw air through the oil, making a sort of noisy sucking sound (like "Sssshhh !"). Yes, just like when you rudely sip a hot broth.

What's the point? It's not a sommelier's whim. The incoming air vaporizes the oil in the mouth and pushes the aromatic molecules toward the nose, passing through the "back" of the throat (technically called retronasal perception ). This is where the oil explodes and reveals its true essence.

Step 4: Judgment (Gustatory and Tactile Analysis)

Swish the oil around your mouth for a few seconds, making sure it touches your tongue and palate, then swallow (or spit, if you need to taste a lot). Listen for the final sensations.

The Benefits: Bitter and Spicy

Don't be scared! What will you hear?

• Bitterness: You'll feel it on your tongue, especially on the sides and bottom. Remember: bitterness isn't a flaw ; it's a characteristic of olives rich in Oleuropein .
• Pungency: You'll feel it in your throat a moment after swallowing (or during stripping). It's the signature of oleocanthal , the anti-inflammatory polyphenol. A balanced oil will have these two components well-balanced with the fruit's aroma.

The Defects: The Enemies of Extra Virgin Olive Oil

If you notice these unpleasant flavors, the oil has production or storage defects:

• Reheating: Tastes like huddled olives, cheese, or spoiled brine. (Cause: Olives stored too long before pressing.)
• Sludge: Tastes like dirt, sewage, or the "bottom of a bottle." (Cause: Unfiltered oil left on the sediment.)
• Rancid: The classic "old" smell of oxidized grease or paint. (Cause: Old oil or oil left exposed to light/air.)
• Winey: Tastes like vinegar, wine, or nail polish. (Cause: alcoholic fermentation of olives.)

The SommOlier's advice

Next time you buy an oil, do this test before using it on food. If you smell grass, artichoke, and that nice tingle aftertaste that makes you cough slightly, smile : you've got a bargain and bought pure health . If it's flat, cloyingly sweet, or smells stale... well, use it to grease the hinges of squeaky doors!

Want to train your palate with flawless oils?

👉 Discover my selection of certified and award-winning extra virgin olive oils

Do you have doubts about an oil you bought?

👉 [Download the Oil Defects Guide to quickly spot them] or Contact me